Every product is independently reviewed and selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.
Choosing the right clove is the first step toward a successful garlic harvest. When fall planting season arrives, not all garlic varieties perform the same, and selecting the best garlic for fall planting can make a noticeable difference in bulb size, flavor, and winter survival. Climate, soil conditions, and growing time all influence which garlic thrives in colder months. From hardy types that tolerate frost to flavorful options prized by home gardeners, understanding your choices helps set the stage for strong root development and a rewarding harvest in the months ahead.
1. Understand the Two Main Types: Hardneck vs. Softneck
| Type | Best For | Flavor & Use | Climate Suitability | Storage Life |
| Hardneck Garlic (Allium sativum var. ophioscorodon) | Gardeners who want bold flavor and easy peeling cloves | More complex, spicy, and aromatic | Best in colder northern climates (Zones 3–7) | 4–6 months |
| Softneck Garlic (Allium sativum var. sativum) | Cooks who want longer storage and mild flavor | Milder, adaptable, often used for braids | Thrives in milder southern climates (Zones 7–10) | 8–12 months |
In my experience: If you live in the northern half of the U.S. (think New England, the Midwest, or the Pacific Northwest), hardneck garlic varieties perform best. In warmer southern or coastal states, softneck types are more reliable through winter.
2. Top Hardneck Varieties for Fall Planting
- ‘Music’ – A classic for home gardeners. Large, easy-to-peel cloves with a rich, balanced flavor. Very cold-hardy.
- ‘German Extra Hardy’ – Consistent performer in cold climates; strong flavor, thick wrappers for better winter protection.
- ‘Chesnok Red’ – Excellent for roasting; holds flavor after cooking.
- ‘Spanish Roja’ – A favorite among chefs for its deep, old-world garlic flavor, though it prefers well-drained soil.
3. Top Softneck Varieties for Fall Planting
- ‘Inchelium Red’ A popular U.S. heirloom from Washington State; mild, rich flavor with excellent storage.
- ‘California Early’ and ‘California Late’ Reliable choices for southern gardeners; easy to grow and widely available.
- ‘Silverskin’ types Great for braiding and long-term storage; ideal in warmer regions.
4. When to Plant Garlic in the United States
- Northern states (Zones 3–6): Late September to mid-October, before the ground freezes.
- Warmer states (Zones 7–10): October to December about 2–4 weeks before your ground cools to 40°F.
Plant cloves root side down, 2 inches deep, and 6 inches apart in loose, well-drained soil rich in organic matter. Mulch with clean straw or shredded leaves for insulation.
5. Pro Tips from the Field
- Always plant certified seed garlic, not grocery-store bulbs (which are often treated to prevent sprouting).
- Rotate your garlic bed yearly to avoid soil-borne diseases.
- Top-dress with organic compost in early spring for healthy growth.
- Harvest when the lower 2–3 leaves turn brown, then cure bulbs for two weeks in a dry, airy place.