Every product is independently reviewed and selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.
Banana peel liquid fertilizer is popular among home gardeners because it’s cheap, natural, and easy to make. But after testing it on container plants, raised beds, and balcony gardens over several seasons, I’ve seen enough drawbacks that I rarely recommend it anymore at least not in the way most online tips suggest.
Here are the real, experience-based disadvantages of banana peel liquid fertilizer, explained simply so you can decide whether it’s right for your garden.
Main Disadvantages of Banana Peel Liquid Fertilizer
1. It Has Very Little Nutritional Value
Banana peels do not contain meaningful amounts of nitrogen something almost all plants need for healthy leaf growth. The liquid produced by soaking peels contains even less.
In real garden trials, I’ve noticed:
- Leaf yellowing (nitrogen deficiency)
- Slow, weak growth
- No improvement in blooming compared to balanced fertilizer
Banana peel water simply can’t feed plants the way many blogs claim.
2. It Can Attract Pests
When I tested banana peel liquid on balcony containers, it consistently attracted:
- Ants
- Fruit flies
- Fungus gnats
- Occasionally cockroaches (in warm climates)
The sugary residue in the water makes an easy target for pests especially in outdoor containers or indoor houseplants.
3. Risk of Mold and Bacterial Growth
Fermented banana peel water often becomes slimy or cloudy.
This can lead to:
- Mold on soil surface
- Sour smells
- Rotting roots (in pots with poor drainage)
I’ve had to repot more than one plant after using banana-water mixtures that went anaerobic.
4. Potassium Levels Are Not as High as Claimed
Banana peels do contain potassium, but soaking them in water doesn’t extract much of it. Lab tests show extremely low nutrient transfer via soaking.
So the main reason people use banana fertilizer boosting flowering isn’t achieved in practice.
5. May Alter Soil pH (Slightly)
Repeated use of homemade plant “teas” can nudge soil pH in unpredictable ways. In containers or small raised beds, this is more noticeable.
I’ve seen slight alkalinity increases when used too often enough to affect acid-loving plants like:
- Blueberries
- Gardenias
- Azaleas
6. Inconsistent and Unpredictable
Because homemade banana peel fertilizer isn’t measured or standardized:
- Nutrient levels vary
- Fermentation speeds differ
- Risk of contamination is high
- You can’t adjust it to your plant’s needs
In gardening, consistency matters and banana water simply isn’t consistent.
7. It Can Compete With Soil Microbes
Peel water sometimes encourages fast-growing bacteria that can temporarily overwhelm beneficial soil microbes. This isn’t catastrophic, but it delays nutrient cycling something I’ve noticed especially in smaller pots.
When Banana Peel Liquid Fertilizer Is Particularly Problematic
Avoid using it for:
- Indoor plants
- Succulents or cacti
- Seedlings
- Plants recovering from disease
- Watered-in fertilizers for potted plants (drainage issues)
It’s slightly safer in large outdoor beds where soil volume dilutes the liquid.
Safer Alternatives for Beginner Gardeners
1. Compost or Worm Castings
Balanced, gentle, and proven effective.
2. Seaweed/Kelp Fertilizer
Excellent micronutrient source without pest issues.
3. Balanced Organic Granular Fertilizer
Feeds slowly and evenly ideal for roses, tomatoes, herbs, and houseplants.
4. Banana Peels in Compost (Not in Water)
If you still want to use banana peels, composting them is the safest and most nutrient-efficient method.
Conclusion
Banana peel liquid fertilizer sounds eco-friendly and clever, but in real garden use it often causes more issues than benefits. Between the low nutrient value, pest attraction, mold risk, and inconsistency, it’s simply not a reliable fertilizer especially for beginner gardeners.
If you want healthy, productive plants, use proven organic fertilizers and compost, and skip the banana peel water trend.